From CBS Sports blog by Greg Doyel:
Leave it to the women to show the men how to fire up MMA crowdCOLUMBUS, Ohio -- Women headlined the Strikeforce card here Saturday night, and the crowd was brutal. It was yelling awful things during the action, things like "prom night" and "those are love taps" and "make love, not war!"
The crowd was onto something, because that was a bad fight. But that wasn't the women. It was the men, the final men's fight of the night, a headliner-quality affair between former Strikeforce lightweight champion Josh Thomson and K.J. Noons. They were rolling and tiptoeing around the mat, fighting more to survive than to destroy, and the crowd was having none of it.
At one point some guy in the first row yelled at Thomson and Noons, "Girls fight better than you!"
And he was right. A bit sexist, maybe -- girls, really? -- but ultimately correct. The women did fight better than Thomson and Noons on Saturday night. They fought better than Paul Daley and Kaz Misaki. Better than Lumumba Sayers and Scott Smith. And better than Bristol Marunde and Ronaldo "Jacare" Souza.
The women had the best two fights of the night, starting of course with the main event, in which challenger Ronda Rousey took Miesha Tate's bantamweight belt, and the better part of her left arm, with a gruesome finish that the uninitiated might not have expected from women.
But women's MMA is not women's basketball. It's not women's golf. It's not an inferior product to the men's version, is what I'm saying. I'm not going to spend any time backing up that assertion, that women's basketball and women's golf are inferior to the men's versions, other than stating these facts: Women basketball players use a smaller ball and play below almost exclusively the rim; women golfers use shorter tees.
Women's MMA? Same five-minute rounds as the men. Same five-round title bouts. Same elbows, fists, knees. Same submissions. Same knockouts.
Same violence.
That's not to say, at the top of the food chain, that a female fighter could beat a male fighter. Do I think Ronda Rousey could beat the best 135-pound male MMA fighter in the world, UFC champion Dominick Cruz? No, of course she couldn't. Maybe if everything went right, and she used her world-class judo to get Cruz to the ground before slapping on her brutal arm bar, Rousey could beat Cruz -- maybe. But if they fought 10 times, I'd bet everything I had on Cruz to win all 10. And he probably would win devastatingly.
The point here is not that female MMA fighters belong in the same cage as the men. They don't, and nobody wants to see that. But female MMA fighters belong on the same fight card as the men, even at the top of the fight card, as Saturday night proved.
Hell, the women didn't just put on the best fight of the night -- they put on the second-best fight, too. And one of them wasn't even aired. Showtime stashed Sarah Kaufman and Alexis Davis on the undercard, which means the viewing audience lost out because Kaufman and Davis put on a show.
"That's what you wanna see, right? You wanna see a fight!" the victorious Kaufman screamed afterward, the crowd screaming at her in return. "You don't wanna see two girls parading around, not fighting. You wanna see a fight."
And they saw it. Kaufman and Davis traded punches for 15 minutes. They were the fourth fight of the night, but when Kaufman and Davis went toe-to-toe late in the first round, the crowd erupted for the first time all night. Blood was on both the fighters' faces, all of it belonging to Davis (until she got even later and drew blood of her own). When rounds ended, the crowd stood and cheered. During the action, the crowd was buzzing.
And this was a crowd that had to be convinced. A few minutes into the fight, it was so quiet that you could hear some idiot yell, "Why are they wearing shirts?" Nobody laughed, because it wasn't funny. In fact, the idiot noticed that nobody laughed and whined, "Tough crowd, because I know that was funny."
Well, no. It wasn't. But the crowd wasn't buzzing early in the fight, either. It was watching two women fight, unsure how to react, until the blood started flowing and the exchanges started happening and Davis started licking the blood off her lips and smiling at Kaufman. And pretty soon, you could tell something had changed inside Nationwide Arena.
The crowd wasn't watching two female fighters.
The crowd was watching two fighters.
More fighters came and went, but the crowd couldn't get into it. Not when it was the men. Souza defeated Marunde in a grinding affair that drew hoots from the crowd. Sayers submitted Smith in the first round, ending the fight before it could get started. A few minutes later both fighters walked past me on press row, and had I not seen the fight with my own eyes, I wouldn't have known who had won or lost. Or that they had fought at all.
Misaki beat Daley in a split decision that had decent action, but nothing more. It was decent. Take it, leave it. I'd tell you more about it, but I've already forgotten what happened.
Thomson and Noons? I remember that one. And what I remember are the boos that greeted the fighters at the end of all three rounds. That was a fight that could turn off viewers.
And then came Miesha Tate and Ronda Rousey to turn them back on. The crowd loved Tate vs. Rousey because the build-up was so visceral, so personal, what with Tate saying Rousey had talked her way into the title shot after a meager four professional fights. And Tate was right; Rousey had talked her way into the title fight. But she deserved it, and she showed it by surviving an early haymaker to the jaw, then nearly submitting Tate in the first minute before finishing the job late in the round.
When it was over, Tate's elbow was bending the wrong way, something Rousey has done to earlier opponents and something she will surely do again. Rousey has the most devastating arm-bar in MMA, male or female, and with Tate's help they put on one of the more entertaining fights of the year.
But only the second-most entertaining fight of the night. The best one I saw? Sarah Kaufman vs. Alexis Davis.